Cinderella Smith got her name because she is always losing her shoes, and she's gone and done it again. But this time it's her brand new tap shoe, and if she doesn't have it, she can't possibly be the Pumpkin Blossom Fairy in the dance recital. She needs to find that shoe, and find it fast. In the meantime though, she is thrilled that the new girl at school, Erin, has reached out to her (and NOT Rosemary), but it's because she wants advice about wicked stepsisters. Alas, maybe Erin doesn't realize that Cinderella doesn't have any stepsisters, wicked or otherwise. Will she still want to be friends if Cinderella can't help her out?